Main Article Content

Saleh Yaseen Abdul Rahman
harith_abd2016@tu.edu.iq
Firas Saadoun Fadel
harith_abd2016@tu.edu.iq

Abstract

This study deals with the subject of (no measurement in worship) which is not valid to be used at all, and it is misplaced, because this use deviates from the doctrinal and fundamentalist framework in which scientists spoke, and we have mentioned the difference of scientists in the explanation of worship and measurement on two doctrines. The researchers mentioned a number of issues in which the doctrines of the four schools or some of them to make the measurement in a matter because it is reasonable sense, or not conducted because it is stoppage or devotional. However, it is evident that the jurisprudential criticism of the behavior of many contemporaries of the expansion and extravagance of prevention by using a rule (not measuring in worship) is launched without deliberating the issue whether it is sensible or unreasonable meaning. There are many findings reached by the researchers through the jurisprudence issues mentioned in the content of the study and the previous demands - mentioned by researchers in the form of issues divided according to the doors of jurisprudence especially the door of purity, prayer, fasting, zakat and Hajj. Here it is for non-repetition, which contribute to stimulate the abilities of researchers to go to the writing of this research in other branches of jurisprudence.

Metrics

Metrics Loading ...

Article Details

How to Cite
Abdul Rahman, S. Y., & Fadel, F. S. (2019). Jurisprudence of Worship between Measurement and Application: A Comparative Study. Journal of Tikrit University for Humanities, 26(12), 73–93. https://doi.org/10.25130/jtuh.26.12.2019.04
Section
Articles

References

baed alquran alkarim

al'iibhaj fi sharah almunhaj, shaykh al'islam eali bin eabd alkafi alsabkiu (almutawafaa: 756 h) wawaladuh taj aldiyn eabd alwahhab bin eali alsabki (almutawafaa: 771 h) dirasat wthqyq: alduktur 'ahmad jamal alzamzimi - alduktur nur aldiyn eabd aljabbar sghiri, dar albihwth lildirasat al'iislamiat wa'iihya' altarathi, altbet: al'uwlaa 1424 h - 2004 m.

al'iihkam fi 'usul al'ahkami, 'abu muhamad eali bin 'ahmad bin saeid bin hizm al'undilsii alqirtabii alzzahirii (almutawafaa: 456 ha) almhqq: alshaykh 'ahmad muhamad shakir, qadam laha: al'ustadh alduktur 'iihsan eibaas, dar alafaq aljadidat, bayrut.

al'iihkam fi aswil alaihkam, 'abu alhasan syd aldiyn eali bin 'abi eali bin muhamad bin salim althaelbii alamadii (almutawafaa: 631 ha) almhqq: eabd alrazzaq eafifi, almaktab al'iislami, biruta- damashq- lubnan.

alaikhtiar litaelil almukhtari, eabd allah bin mahmud bin mawdud almawsilii albldahi, mjd aldiyn 'abu alfadl alhanafii (almutawafaa: 683 h) taeliqat: alshaykh mahmud 'abu dqyqt, mutbaeat alhalbi - alqahr (wswratuha dar alkutub aleilmiat - birut) 1356 h - 1937 m.

alaistidhkaru, 'abu eumar yusif bin eabd allh bin muhamad bin eabd albar bin easim alnamrii alqurtabii (almutawafaa: 463 h) thqyq: salim muhamad eata, muhamad eali mueawad, dar alkutub aleilmiat - bayrut, altbet: alawlaa، 1421-2000.

aswil alsarkhasay, muhamad bin 'ahmad bin 'abi sahl shams al'ayimat alsarakhsii (almutawafaa: 483 ha) dar almaerifat - bayrut.

'asul alfaqih aldhy la yasie alfaqiuh jahalahu, eyad bin nami bin eiwad alsilmii, dar altadmuriata, alriyad - almamlakat alearabiat alsaeudiat, altbet: al'uwlaa 1426 h - 2005 m.

'iieanat alttalibayn ealaa hali 'alfaz fath almuein (hw hashiatan ealaa fath almuein bishrh qurat aleayn bimuhammat aldyn) 'abu bakr (almashhur balbkry) bin muhamad shataan aldamiatii (almutawafaa: baed 1302 h) dar alfikr liltibaeat walnashr waltawriei, altabeat: al'uwlaa, 1418 h - 1997 m.

'iielam almuaqiein ean rabi alealamini, 'abu eabd allah muhamad bin 'abi bikr bin 'ayuwb almaeruf biaibn qiam aljawzia (almutawafaa: 751 h) qadam lah waealaq ealayh wakharaj 'ahadithih wathariha: 'abu eabidat mashhur bin hasan al sulmani, dar abn aljawzii lilnashr waltawziei, almamlakat alearabiat alsaeudiat altbet: al'uwlaa 1423 h.

al'umu alshshafieiu 'abu eabd allah muhamad bin 'iidris bin aleabbas bin euthman bin shafie bin eabd almatlab bin eabd manaf almutlabii alqarshii almakia (almutawafaa: 204 h) dar almaerifat - bayrutu, bidun tabeat 1410 h / 1990 m.

albijirmiu ealaa alkhatib (ithafat alhabib ealaa sharah alkhatib = hashiat albijirmii ealaa alkhatib), sulayman bin muhamad bin eumar albijirmii almisrii alshshafieii (almutawafaa 1221 h) dar alfikr, bidun tabeat 1415 h - 1995 m.

albahr alraayiq sharah kanz aldaqayiq, zayn aldiyn abn najim alhinfi (926 h- 970 h) dar almuerifati, bayrut.

albahr almuhit fi 'usul alfaqihi, 'abu eabd allah badr aldiyn muhamad bin eabd allh bin bihadir alzarkashii (almutawafaa: 794 h) dar alktbi, altbet: al'uwlaa 1414 h - 1994 m.

bahr almadhhibi, alruwyani, 'abu almuhasin eabd alwahid bin 'iismaeil (t 502 h) almhqq: tariq fathi alsayd, dar alkutub alealmiatu, altbet: al'uwlaa 2009 m.

badayie alsanayie fi tartib alsharayiei, eala' aldiyn, 'abu bakr bin maseud bin 'ahmad alkasani alhanafii (almutawafaa: 587 h) dar alkutub aleilmiat, altbet: alththaniat 1406 h - 1986 m.

albinayat sharah alhdayt, 'abu muhamad mahmud bin 'ahmad bin musaa bin 'ahmad bin husayn alghitaba alhanfaa badr aldiyn aleaynaa (almutawafaa: 855 h) dar alkutub aleilmiat - bayrut, lubnan, altbet: al'uwlaa 1420 h - 2000 m.

albayan fi madhhab al'imam alshshafiei, 'abu alhusayn yahyaa bin 'abi alkhayr bin salim aleumranii alyamanii alshshafieii (almutawafaa: 558 h) almhqq: qasim muhamad alnuwri, dar almunhaj - jdt, altbet: al'uwlaa 1421 h- 2000 m.

altahbir sharah altahriri, eala' aldiyn 'abu alhasan eali bin sulayman almardawi aldimashaqii alssalihii alhanbalii (almutawafaa: 885 h) almuhaqaq: d. eabd alrahmin aljabrin, d. eiwad alqarnii, d. 'ahmad alsirahi, maktabat alrushd - alsewdyt / alriyad, altbet: al'uwlaa 1421 h - 2000 m.

tuhfat alfuqaha'i, muhamad bin 'ahmad bin 'abi 'ahmad, 'abu bakr eala' aldiyn alssmrqndy (almutawafaa: nahw 540 h) dar alkutub aleilmiati, bayrut - lubnan, altbet: alththaniat 1414 h - 1994 m.

tuhfat almuhtaj fi sharah almunhaj, 'ahmad bin muhamad bin eali bin hajar alhitmi, rawajaeat wasahahat: ealaa edt naskh bimaerifat lajnat min aleulama'i, almaktabat altijariat alkubraa bimisr lisahibiha mustafaa muhmid, bidun tabeat, 1357 h - 1983 m.

takhrij alfurue ealaa al'usuli, mahmud bin 'ahmad bin mahmud bin bakhtiar, 'abu almanaqib shihab aldiyn alzanjanii (almutawafaa: 656 ha) almuhaqaq: da. muhamad 'udib salihu, muasasat alrisalat - byrwt, altbet: althaaniat, 1398 h.

altalaqiyn fi alfaqih almalki, 'abu muhamad eabd alwahhab bin eali bin nasr althaelabi albighdadii almalikii (almutawafaa: 422 h) almhqq: 'abi 'uwis muhamad bu khabizat alhusni altitwani, dar alkutub aleilmiatu, altbet: al'uwlaa 1425 h -2004 m.

aljamie limasayil almudunati, 'abu bakr muhamad bin eabd allh bin yunis altamimii alsiqlayi (almutawafaa: 451 h) almhqq: majmueat bahithin fi rasayil dukturah, maehad albihwth aleilmiat wa'iihya' alturath al'iislamii - jamieatan 'ama alquraa (slaslat alrasayil aljamieiat almusaa btbeha) dar alfikr liltibaeat walnashr waltawzie altbet: al'uwlaa, 1434 h - 2013 m.

jawahir aleuqud wamuein alqudat walmuaqiein walshuhudi, shams aldiyn muhamad bin 'ahmad almunhaji al'asyutii (almutawafaa: 880 h) haqaqaha wakharaj 'ahadithiha msed eabd alhamid muhamad alsedni, dar alkutub aleilmiat- bayurut.

aljawhrat alniyratu, 'abu bakr bin eali bin muhamad alhadadii aleabbadii alzubaydii alyamanii alhanafii (almutawafaa: 800 ha) almutbaeat alkhayriatu, altabiet: al'uwlaa, 1322 h.

hashiat abn eabidin (rd almihtar ealaa alduri almkhtar) liaibn eabidin, muhamad 'amin bin eumar bin eabd aleaziz eabidin aldamashaqii alhanafii (almutawafaa 1252 h) dar alfakr-birut, altbet: alththaniat 1412 h - 1992 m.

hashiat aleadawii ealaa sharah kifayat altaalib alrabani, 'abu alhsn, eali bin 'ahmad bin mukrim alsaeidii aleadawii (almutawafaa: 1189 h) almhqq: yusif alshaykh muhamad albqaey, dar alfikr - bayrut, bidun tabeat 1414 h - 1994 m.

alhawi alkabir fi faqih mudhhab al'imam alshaafieii wahu sharah mukhtasir almazni, 'abu alhasan eali bin muhamad bin muhamad bin habib albasri albaghdadi, alshahir bialmawrdii (almutawafaa: 450 ha) almahqaqa: alshaykh eali muhamad mueawad - alshaykh eadil 'ahmad eabd almawjawid, dar alkutub aleilmiat , bayrut - lubnan, altbet: al'uwlaa 1419 h m -1999.

alhujat ela ahl almadinati, 'abu eabd allah muhamad bin alhasan bin faraqd alshayabanii (almutawafaa: 189 h) almhqq: mahdi hasan alkaylanii alqadirii, ealam alkutub - bayrut, altbet: alththalithat 1403 h.

alhudud al'aniqat waltaerifat aldaqiqatu, zakariaaan bin muhamad bin 'ahmad bin zakariaa al'ansari, zayn aldiyn 'abu yahyaa alsaniki (almutawafaa: 926 ha) almuhaqaqa: da. mazin almubarik, dar alfikr almueasir - bayrut, altbet: al'uwlaa 1411 h.

alduru almukhtar abn eabidayn, muhamad 'amin bin eumar bin eabd aleaziz eabidin aldamashaqii alhanafii (almutawafaa 1252 h) dar alfakr-birut, altbet: alththaniat 1412 h - 1992 m.

aldhkhirt, 'abu aleabbas shihab aldiyn 'ahmad bin 'iidris bin eabd alruhmin almaliki alshahir bialqarafii (almutawaffa: 684 h) almhqq: juz' 1, 8, 13: muhamad haji, juz' 2, 6 saeid 'aerab, juz' 3-5, 7, 12/9: muhamad bu khabizat, dar algharb al'islamy- byrwt, altbet: al'uwlaa 1994 m.

rada almuhtar ealaa alduri almukhtari, abn eabidin muhamad 'amin bin eumar bin eabd aleaziz eabidin aldamashaqii alhanafii (almutawafaa 1252 h) dar alfakr-birut, altbet: alththaniati, 1412 h - 1992 m.

sharah altalwih ealaa altawdihi, saed aldiyn maseud bin eumar altafataazanii (almutawafaa: 793 ha) alnashr: maktabat sabih bimasri, bidun tibeat wabidun tarikh.

sharah alzarkashi ealaa mukhtasar alkharqi, shams aldiyn muhamad bin eabd allh alzarkashi almisria alhnbli (almutawafaa: 772 h) dar aleibaykan, altbet: al'uwlaa, 1413 h - 1993 m.

alsharah alkabir ealaa matn almaqnaei, eabd alruhmin bin muhamad bin 'ahmad bin qadamat almaqdisii aljimaeilii alhunbili, 'abu alfarj, shams aldiyn (almutawafaa: 682 h) dar alkitab alearabii lilnashr waltawziei, 'ashraf ealaa tibaeatih: muhamad rashid rida sahib almanar.

sharah alkawkab almunir, taqi aldiyn 'abu albaqa' muhamad bin 'ahmad bin eabd aleaziz bin eali alfutuhi almaeruf biaibn alnijar alhanbalii (almutawafaa: 972 h) almuhaqaq: muhamad alzahili wanazih hamad, maktabat aleabaykan, altubeat alththaniat 1418 h - 1997 m.

alsharah almumtieu ealaa zad almustaqnaei, muhamad bin salih bin muhamad aleathimayn (almutawafaa: 1421 h) dar abn aljawzi, altabiet: al'awlaa, 1422-1428 h.

sharah tanqih alfusuli, shihab aldiyn 'ahmad bin 'iidris alsinhajii alqarafii (t 684 h) dirasatan wthqyq: risalatan muqadimatan linil darajat almajstyr fi aldirasat al'iislamiati, 'iiedad altalb: nasir bin eali bin nasir alghamidi, 'iishraf: fadilat alshaykh al'ustadh alduktur hamzat bin husayn alfier 1421 h / 2000 m.

shifa' alealil fi masayil alqada' walqadr walhikmat waltaelili, muhamad bin 'abi bikr bin 'ayuwb bin saed shams aldiyn (almutawafaa: 751 h) dar almaerifati, bayrut, lubnan, 1398 h / 1978 m.

sahih albikhari = aljamie almusanad alsahih almukhtasar min 'umur rasul allah salaa allah ealayh wasalam wasananh wa'ayaamuhu, muhamad bin 'iismaeil 'abu eabdallh albikhari aljiefay, almuhaqaqa: muhamad zahir bin nasir alnaasir, dar tuq alnaja (msurat ean alsultaniat bi'iidafat tarqim tarqim muhamad fuad eabd albaqi ) altbet: al'uwlaa, 1422 h.

sahih maslimi, muslim bin alhujaj 'abu alhasan alqashirii alnaysaburii (almutawafaa: 261 h) almuhaqaqa: muhamad fuad eabd albaqi, dar 'iihya' alturath alearabii - bayrut.

tariqat alkhilaf fi alfaqih bayn al'ayimat al'aslafi, muhamad bin eabd alhamid al'usmandii (552 h) haqaqah waealaq ealayh wayunashiruh li'awal marat: d. muhamad zaki eabd albir, maktabat dar altarathu, alqahrt - misr, altbet: alththaniatu, 1428 h - 2007 m.

aleidat sharah aleumdata, eabd alruhmin bin 'iibrahim bin 'ahmad, 'abu muhamad biha' aldiyn almaqdisii (almutawafaa: 624 h) dar alhadith, alqahirati, bidun tabeat 1424 h 2003 m.

aleinayat sharah alhadayat, muhamad bin muhamad bin mahmud, 'akmal aldiyn 'abu eabd allah abn alshaykh shams aldiyn abn alshaykh jamal aldiyn alruwmii albabrti (almutawafaa: 786 h) dar alfukr, bidun tabeat wabidun tarikh.

ghayat almaram fi eilm alkalami, almualafa: 'abu alhasan syd aldiyn eali bin 'abi eali bin muhamad bin salim althaelbii alamadii (almutawafaa: 631 ha) almahaqaqa: hasan mahmud eabd allatif, almajlis al'aelaa lilshuyuwn al'iislamiat - alqahirat.

fath alwahhab bshrh manhaj altulabi, zakariaaan bin muhamad bin 'ahmad bin zakariaa al'ansari, zayn aldiyn 'abu yahyaa alsinikia (almutawafaa: 926 h) dar alfikr liltibaeat walnashr 1414 h / 1994 m.

alfurue watashih alfuruei, muhamad bin muflh bin muhamad bin mafrij, 'abu eabd allah, shams aldiyn almaqdisii alrraminaa thuma alssalihiu alhanbaliu (almutawafaa: 763 h) almhqq: eabd allah bin eabd almuhsin alturki, muasasat alrisalat, altbet: al'uwlaa 1424 h - 2003 m.

alfuruqu, 'abu aleibaas shihab aldiyn 'ahmad bin 'iidris bin eabd alrahmin almaliki alshahir bialqarafii (almutawafaa: 684 ha) ealam alkatab, bidun tabeat wabidun tarikh.

alqias fi aleibadati, al'ustadh eadil eabd alwahab, bahath manshur fi mawqie bitarikh 'aghustus / 4/2012 m.

alkashaf ean haqayiq altanzil waeuyun al'aqawil fi wujuh altaawili, 'abi alqasim mahmud bin eumar alzamkhasharii alkhwarzmy, thqyq: eabd alrazzaq almahdi, dar 'iihya' alturath alearabii - bayrut - (d.t, d.t).

kashf almukhdirati, eabd alruhmin bin eabd allh albaeli alhanbalia, (1110 h / h 1192) tahqiq qabilih bi'aslih wathlatht 'usul 'ukhraa: muhamad bin nasir aleajmi, dar albashayir al'iislamiat 1423 h - 2002 m.

kifayat al'akhyar fi hali ghayat alaikhtisari, 'abu bakr bin muhamad bin eabd almumin bin hariz bin muelaa alhusaynii alhisnii, taqi aldiyn alshaafieia (almutawafaa: 829 h) almhqq: eali eabd alhamid biltaji wamuhamad wahabia sulayman, dar alkhayr - damashqu, altbet: al'uwlaa 1994 m.

allabab fi sharah alkitabi, 'abu muhamad eabd allh bin manie bin ghalab alghabiwii alruwqii aleatibii, dar altadamuriatu, alriyad - almamlakat alearabiat alsaeudiat, altbet: al'uwlaa, 1433 h - 2012 m.

almabsut muhamad bin 'ahmad bin 'abi sahl shams al'ayimat alsarukhasii (almutawafaa: 483 h) dar almaerifat - bayrutu, bidun tabeat 1414 h - 1993 m.

almajmue sharah almuhadhib, 'abu zakariaa muhyi aldiyn yahyaa bin sharaf alnawawii (almutawafaa: 676 h) dar alfukr, dun raqm tabeat wasanat nushr.

almahsul, 'abu eabd allah muhamad bin eumar bin alhasan bin alhusayn altiymii alrrazii almulaqab bifakhr aldiyn alrrazi khatib alry (almutawafaa: 606 h) dirasat wthqyq: alduktur th jabir fiad aleulwanii, muasasat alrisalat, altbet: alththalithati, 1418 h - 1997 m.

mukhtar alsahahi, zayn aldiyn 'abu eabd allah muhamad bin 'abi bikr bin eabd alqadir alhanfi alrrazi (almutawafaa: 666 h) almhqq: yusif alshaykh muhmid, almaktabat aleasriat - aldaar alnamudhajiata, bayrut - syda, altbet: alkhamisati, 1420 h / 1999 m.

mukhtasir al'iinsaf walshurh alkabiri, muhamad bin eabd alwahhab bin sulayman altamimia alnajdia (almutawafaa 1206 h) almhqq: eabd aleaziz bin zayd alruwmi, d. muhamad bilitaji, da. syd hijab, matabie alriyad - alriyadu, altbet: al'uwlaa.

mukhtasir alkharqii (mtan alkharqi ealaa madhhib 'abi eabd allah 'ahmad bin hnbl alshiybani) 'abu alqasim eumar bin alhusayn bin eabd allh alkharqi (almutawaffa: 334 h) dar alsahaabat liltarathi, 1413 h -1993 m.

almukhtasir alfuqahiu liaibn eurfat, muhamad bin muhamad abn eurfat alwrghmy altuwnisia almalki, 'abu eabd allah (almutawafaa: 803 h) almhaqaq: d. hafiz eabd alrahmin muhamad khayr, muasasat khalf 'ahmad alkhabtur lil'aemal alkhayryat, altbet: al'uwlaa, 1435 h - 2014 m.

almustasfaa، 'abu hamid muhamad bin muhamad alghazali altawsia (almutawafaa: 505 h) tahqiq:an muhamad eabd alsalam eabd alshafi, dar alkutub aleilmiat, altbet: al'uwlaa, 1413 h - 1993 m.

maealim alsanni, 'abu sulayman hamd bin muhamad bin 'iibrahim bin alkhitab albsty almaeruf bialkhatabii (almutawafaa: 388 h) almutbaeat aleilmiat - halb, altbet: al'uwlaa 1351 h - 1932 m.

almuetamidu, muhamad bin eali altayib 'abu alhusayn albasriu almuetaziliu (almutawafaa: 436 h) almuhaqaqa: khalil almiisi, dar alkutub aleilmiat - bayrut, altabet: al'uwlaa 1403 h.

almaghni, 'abu muhamad muafaq aldiyn eabd allah bin 'ahmad bin muhamad bin qadamat aljamaeilii almaqdisii thuma aldamashaqii alhunbili, alshahir biaibn qadamat almaqdisii (almutawafaa: 620 h) maktabat alqahirati, bidun tabeat.

manar alsabil fi sharah aldalil, abn duyan, 'iibrahim bin muhamad bin salim (almutawafaa 1353 h) almhqq: zahir alshawysh, almaktab al'iislami, altbet: alssabieat 1409 h -1989 m.

almuntaqaa min munhaj alaietidali, shams aldiyn 'abu eabd allah muhamad bin 'ahmad bin euthman bin qaymaz aldhahabii (almutawafaa: 748 h) almahaqaq: mahabu aldiyn alkhatibi, dun raqm tabeat wasanat nushr.

almuhadhab fi faqih al'imam alshaafieii, 'abu 'iishaq 'iibrahim bin eali bin yusif alshayrazii (almutawafaa: 476 h) dar alkutub aleilmiati, dun raqm tabeat wasanat nushr.

almuafaqatu, 'iibrahim bin musaa bin muhamad allkhami alghirnatii alshahir bialshshatibii (almutawafaa: 790 h) almuhaqaq: 'abu eubidat mashhur bin hasan al sulmani, dar abn efan, altabeat al'uwlaa 1417 h / 1997 m.

mawahib aljalili, shams aldiyn 'abu eabd allah muhamad bin muhamad bin eabd alrahmina altarabulsi almaghribi, almaeruf bialhitab alrueinii almalikii (almutwafa: 954 h) dar alfikr, altbet: alththalithat 1412 h - 1992 m.

alnutf fi alfatawaa lilsighdi, 'abu alhasan eali bin alhusayn bin muhamad alsaghdi, hanafi (almutawafaa: 461 h) almhqq: almuhami alduktur salah aldiyn alnnahi, dar alfurqan / muasasat alrisalat - eamman al'urdun / bayrut lubnan, altbet: alththaniatu, 1404-1984 .

nihayat al'iiqdam fi eilm alkalami, 'abu alfath muhamad bin eabd alkarim bin 'abaa bikr 'ahmad alshahrstani (almutawafaa: 548 ha) tahqiqa: 'ahmad farid almazidi, dar alkutub aleilmiat - bayrut, altabet: al'uwlaa / 1425 h.

nihayat alsuwl sharah munhaj alwusuli, eabd alrahim bin alhasan bin eali al'iisnawiu alshshafiei, 'abu muhamid, jamal aldiyn (almutawafaa: 772 h) dar alkutub aleilmiat -byrut-libnan, altbet: al'uwlaa 1420 h- 1999 m.

nihayat almuhtaj 'iilaa sharh almunhaji, shams aldiyn muhamad bin 'abi aleabbas 'ahmad bin hamzat shihab aldiyn alramlia (almutawafaa 1004 h) dar alfikr, bayrut, altabeat al'akhirat - 1404 h / 1984 m.

alnuwadir walziyadat ealaa ma fi almudunati, 'abu muhamad eabd allh bin (abi zyd) eabd alruhmin alnafzi, alqirwani, almalikiu (almutawafaa: 386 h) tahqiq: j 1, 2: alduktur eabd alfattah muhamad alhuluw, j 3, 4 alduktur muhamad haji, j 5, 7, 9, 10, 11, 13: al'ustadh muhamad eabd aleaziz aldabagh, j 6: alduktur eabd allh almurabit altarghi, al'ustadh / muhamad eabd aleaziz aldabagh, j 8: al'ustadh muhamad al'amin bukhbzt, j 12: alduktur 'ahmad alkhatabi, al'ustadh muhamad eabd aleaziz aldabagh, j 14, 15 (alfhars): alduktur muhamad hajy, dar algharb al'iislami, bayrut, altbet: al'uwlaa 1999 m.