Doubt among the Muhaddithin (Scholars of Hadith): Its Cause, Types, and Relationship to the Cause
Article Sidebar
Main Article Content
Abstract
It is known that the Sunnah of the Prophet (Peace be upon him) has received great attention among the companions who conveyed the task of re-telling Al-HAdith, as they served the Sunnah a great service. They preserved it from distortion, forgery and mixing.
They took great care in transmitting the narration, which led to the occurrence of doubt on the part of many narrators as a result of their eagerness to transmit the hadith as it is, and to protect them from narrating the hadith with meaning.
The skepticism from the narrators, especially the trustworthy ones, is evidence of their caution in transmitting the narration as he heard it, without performing it with meaning.
This research studies the words that the narrators doubted in the body of the hadith, and it has an impact on the doctrinal aspect, or jurisprudence, or what has to do with people, time, place, and so on.
This study is a conceptual introduction to review the concept of doubt.
As well as also it attempts at clarifying the reasons that lead to doubt, with the inference for each of those reasons, then explaining its types, and presents a clarification of the relationship between doubt and the cause.
Metrics
Article Details
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.
References
بعد القرآن الكريم: After the Holy Quran
The impact of the narrator’s doubt about the acceptance or rejection of the hadith - an applied study, Taha Hamid Huraish Al Fahdawi, Baghdad - Shams Al-Andalus Office, first edition, 2017 AD.
The impact of the ills of hadith in the differences of jurists, Maher Yassin Fahl, Amman - Dar Ammar, first edition, 1420 AH - 2000 AD.
The basis of rhetoric, Abu Al-Qasim, Mahmoud bin Amr bin Ahmed, Al-Zamakhshari Jarallah, (T.: 538 AH), investigation: Muhammad Basil Oyoun Al-Soud, Beirut - Dar Al-Kutub Al-Ilmiyya, first edition, 1419 AH - 1998 AD.
The words that the narrators doubted in the Sahih of Imam Muslim - a comparative analytical study, Saed Ahmad Abd Shannar, a doctoral thesis, presented at the International University of Islamic Sciences - College of Graduate Studies - Jordan, and discussed in: 2017 AD.
History of Abu Zara’ah al-Dimashqi, Abd al-Rahman bin Amr bin Abdullah bin Safwan al-Nasri, known as Abu Zara’ al-Dimashqi, nicknamed the Sheikh of Youth, (died: 281 AH), narrated by: Abu Maymoon bin Rashid, investigation: Shukr Allah Ni’mat Allah al-Qujani, Damascus - Arabic Language Academy.
Al-Tarikh Al-Kabeer, Abu Abdullah, Muhammad bin Ismail bin Ibrahim Al-Bukhari Al-Jaafi, (T.: 256 AH), printed under the supervision of: Muhammad Abdul Mu`id Khan, India - Hyderabad - Deccan - Ottoman Encyclopedia.
Definitions, Ali bin Muhammad bin Ali Al-Zain Al-Sharif Al-Jerjani, (T.: 816 AH), investigation: controlled and corrected by a group of scholars under the supervision of the publisher, Beirut - Dar Al-Kutub Al-Ilmiyya, first edition, 1403 AH - 1983AD.
Tahdheeb Al-Tahdheeb, Abu Al-Fadl, Ahmed bin Ali bin Muhammad bin Ahmed bin Hajar Al-Asqalani, (852 AH), India - The Systematic Knowledge Circle Press, first edition, 1326 AH.
Refining the language, Abu Mansour, Muhammad bin Ahmed bin Al-Azhari Al-Harawi, (T.: 370 AH), investigation: Muhammad Awad Mereb, House of Revival of Arab Heritage - Beirut, first edition, 2001 AD.
Directing Attention to the Origins of Athar, Taher Bin Saleh (or Muhammad Saleh) Ibn Ahmed Bin Mohab, Al-Sam’uni Al-Jaza’iri, then Al-Dimashqi, (T.: 1338 AH), investigated by: Abdel Fattah Abu Ghaddah, Aleppo - Islamic Publications Library, first edition, 1416 AH - 1995 AD.
Arrest on Definitions Tasks, Zain al-Din Muhammad, called Abd al-Raouf bin Taj al-Arefin bin Ali bin Zain al-Abidin al-Hadadi and then al-Manawi al-Qahiri, (died: 1031 AH), Cairo - World of Books, first edition, 1410 AH - 1990 AD.
Al-Jami’ Al-Musnad Al-Sahih Al-Bukhari from the matters of the Messenger of God and his Sunnah and his days, famous for Sahih Al-Bukhari, Abu Abdullah, Muhammad bin Ismail Al-Ja’fi Al-Bukhari, (T.: 256 AH), a new corrected, corrected and indexed edition, Damascus - Beirut - Dar Ibn Katheer, first edition, 1423 AH_2002AD.
The Collector of the Ethics of the Narrator and the Etiquette of the Listener, Abu Bakr, Ahmed bin Ali bin Thabit bin Ahmed bin Mahdi Al-Khatib Al-Baghdadi, (T.: 463 AH), investigation: Dr. Mahmoud Al-Tahan, Riyadh - Al-Maaref Library.
Sunan Abi Dawood, Abu Dawood, Suleiman bin Al-Ash’ath bin Ishaq bin Bashir bin Shaddad bin Amr Al-Azdi Al-Sijistani, (275 AH), investigation: Muhammad Muhyi Al-Din Abdul Hamid, Beirut - Al-Asriya Library.
Sunan Al-Dar Qatni, Abu Al-Hasan, Ali bin Omar bin Ahmed bin Mahdi bin Masoud bin Al-Numan bin Dinar Al-Baghdadi Al-Dar Qatni, (385 AH), investigation: Shuaib Al-Arnaout, Beirut - Al-Resala Foundation, first edition, 1424 AH - 2004 AD.
Al-Sunan Al-Kubra, Abu Bakr, Ahmed bin Al-Hussein bin Ali bin Musa Al-Khusrujardi Al-Khorasani, Al-Bayhaqi, (458 AH), investigation: Muhammad Abdul Qadir Atta, Beirut - Dar Al-Kutub Al-Ilmia, third edition, 1424 AH - 2003 AD.
Explanation of the ills of al-Tirmidhi, Zain al-Din Abd al-Rahman ibn Ahmad ibn Rajab ibn al-Hasan, al-Salami, al-Baghdadi, then al-Dimashqi, al-Hanbali, (T.: 795 AH), investigation: Dr. Hammam Abdul Rahim Saeed, Jordan - Zarqa - Al-Manar Library, first edition, 1407 AH - 1987 AD.
The narrator’s doubt and its impact on the hadiths of rulings, Yahya Kahloul, PhD thesis, University of Algiers, Faculty of Islamic Sciences - Department of Beliefs and Religions, academic year: 2016-2017 SD.
Doubt in the performance of the novel, its causes and the modernists’ approach to preventing it, and it is a published research. Look for the search card on the World Wide Web.
Doubt about the narration among the modernists, Hassan Muhammed Abba Ji, a research published in the Journal of King Saud University - Riyadh, year: 2009 AD.
Al-Sahih Taj Al-Lughah wa Sahih Al-Arabiya, Abu Nasr, Ismail bin Hammad Al-Gawhari Al-Farabi, (T.: 393 AH), investigation: Ahmed Abdel Ghafour Attar, Beirut - Dar Al-Ilm for Millions, fourth edition, 1407 AH - 1987AD.
Sahih Ibn Khuzaymah, Abu Bakr, Muhammad Ibn Ishaq Ibn Khuzaymah Ibn al-Mughirah Ibn Salih Ibn Bakr al-Sulami al-Naysaburi, (311 AH), investigation: Dr. Muhammad Mustafa Al-Adhamy, Beirut - The Islamic Office.
Safeguarding Sahih Muslim from breach and error and protecting it from misstep and fall, Abu Amr, Othman bin Abd al-Rahman, Taqi al-Din known as Ibn al-Salah al-Shahrazuri, (643 AH), investigation: Muwaffaq Abdullah Abdul Qadir, Beirut - Dar al-Gharb al-Islami, second edition, 1408 AH.
The illness and its types for the modernists, Abu Sufyan, Mustafa Bajo, Tanta - Al-Diaa Library, first edition, 1426 AH - 2005 AD.
Umdat al-Qari, Sharh Sahih al-Bukhari, Abu Muhammad, Muhammad ibn Ahmad ibn Musa ibn Ahmad ibn Husayn al-Ghitabi al-Hanafi, Badr al-Din al-Aini, (died: 855 AH), Beirut - House of Revival of Arab Heritage.
Fath Al-Bari, Sharh Sahih Al-Bukhari, Abu Al-Fadl, Ahmed bin Ali bin Hajar Al-Asqalani Al-Shafi’i, (T.: 852 AH), No.: Muhammad Fouad Abdel-Baqi, transcribed and authenticated by: Muhib Al-Din Al-Khatib, Beirut - Dar Al-Maarifa, 1379 AH.
Fath al-Mughith with an explanation of the Millennium of Hadith by al-Iraqi, Abu al-Khair, Muhammad ibn Abd al-Rahman ibn Muhammad ibn Abi Bakr ibn Othman ibn Muhammad al-Sakhawi, (d.: 902 AH), investigated by: Ali Hussein Ali, Egypt - Library of the Sunnah, first edition, 1424 AH - 2003 AD.
Al-Kashef fi Knowing who has a narration in the Six Books, Abu Abdullah, Muhammad bin Ahmed bin Othman bin Qaymaz Al-Dhahabi, (748 AH), investigation: Muhammad Awamah, Ahmad Muhammad Nimr Al-Khatib, Jeddah, Foundation for Quran Sciences - Dar Al-Qibla for Islamic Culture The first edition, 1413 AH-1992 AD.
Al-Kamil fi Weak Men, Abu Ahmed, Abdullah bin Uday bin Abdullah bin Muhammad Al-Jarjani, (T.: 365 AH), investigation: Adel Ahmed Abdel-Mawgod - Ali Muhammad Moawad, Beirut - Dar Al-Kutub Al-Ilmia, first edition, 1418 AH_1997 AD.
The Book of Al-Ain, Abu Abd Al-Rahman, Al-Khalil bin Ahmed bin Amr bin Tamim Al-Farahidi Al-Basri, (T.: 170 AH), investigation: Dr. Mahdi Makhzoumi, Dr. Ibrahim Al-Samarrai, publisher: Al-Hilal House and Library.
Sufficiency in the Science of Novel, Abu Bakr, Ahmed bin Ali bin Thabit bin Ahmed bin Mahdi Al-Khatib Al-Baghdadi, (T.: 463 AH), investigation: Abu Abdullah Al-Souraki, Ibrahim Hamdi Al-Madani, Al-Madinah Al-Munawwarah - Scientific Library.
Colleges, A Dictionary of Terms and Linguistic Differences, Abu Al-Baqa, Ayoub bin Musa Al-Hussaini Al-Quraimi Al-Kafwi, Al-Hanafi, (T.: 1094 AH), investigation: Adnan Darwish - Muhammad Al-Masri, Beirut - Al-Resala Foundation.
Al-Majrouhin from the hadith, the weak and the abandoned, Abu Hatim, Muhammad bin Habban bin Ahmed bin Hibban bin Muadh bin Ma`bad, Al-Tamimi, Al-Darami, Al-Busti, (d.: 354 AH), investigation: Mahmoud Ibrahim Zayed, Aleppo - Dar Al-Wa’i, first edition, 1396 AH.
Al-Majmoo’ Explanation of Al-Muhadhab (with the completion of Al-Subki and Al-Mutai’i), Abu Zakaria, Muhyi Al-Din Yahya bin Sharaf Al-Nawawi, (T.: 676 AH), publisher: Dar Al-Fikr.
Musnad Abi Dawood Al-Tayalisi, Abu Dawood, Suleiman bin Dawood bin Al-Jarud Al-Tayalisi Al-Basri, (204 AH), investigation: Dr. Muhammad bin Abdul Mohsen Al-Turki, Egypt - Dar Hajar, first edition, 1419 AH - 1999 AD.
Musnad of Imam Ahmad bin Hanbal, Abu Abdullah, Ahmed bin Muhammad bin Hanbal bin Hilal bin Asad Al Shaibani, (T.: 241 AH), investigation: Shuaib Al-Arnaout - Adel Murshid, and others, supervision: Dr. Abdullah bin Abdul Mohsen Al-Turki, Publisher: Al-Resala Foundation, first edition, 1421 AH - 2001 AD.
The Sahih Al-Musnad Brief Transfer of Justice from Justice to the Messenger of God , well-known as Sahih Muslim, Abu Al-Hasan, Muslim bin Al-Hajjaj Al-Qushayri Al-Naysaburi, (T.: 261 AH), investigation: Muhammad Fouad Abdel-Baqi, Beirut - House of Revival of Arab Heritage.
The compiler of Ibn Abi Shaybah, Abu Bakr, Abdullah Bin Muhammad Bin Abi Shaybah Al-Absi Al-Kufi, (235 AH), investigation: Muhammad Awamah, the part and page numbers correspond to the edition of the ancient Indian Salafi Dar, and the numbering of hadiths corresponds to the edition of Dar Al-Qibla.
Reading the lights on the health of antiquities, Abu Ishaq, Ibrahim bin Youssef bin Ibrahim Al-Hamzi Al-Wahrani, known as Ibn Qarqul, (d.: 569 AH), investigation: Dar Al-Falah for Scientific Research and Heritage Investigation - Qatar, first edition, 1433 AH - 2012 AD.
The Intermediate Lexicon, the author: The Arabic Language Academy in Cairo (Ibrahim Mustafa, Ahmed Al-Zayyat, Hamed Abdel Qader, Muhammad Al-Najjar, publisher: Dar Al-Da`wah.
A Dictionary of Language Measures, Abu Al-Hussein, Ahmed bin Faris bin Zakaria Al-Qazwini Al-Razi, (T.: 395 AH), investigation: Abd al-Salam Muhammad Harun, Publisher: Dar al-Fikr, 1399 AH - 1979 AD.
Knowing the types of hadith sciences, known by the introduction of Ibn al-Salah, Abu Amr, Othman bin Abd al-Rahman, known as Ibn al-Salah al-Shahrazouri, (T.: 643 AH) investigation: Abd al-Latif al-Hamim - Maher Yassin al-Fahl, publisher - Dar al-Kutub al-Ilmiyya, first edition, 1423 AH _2002 AD.
Mughni Al-Labib on the books of Al-Arabs, Abu Muhammad, Abdullah bin Yusuf bin Ahmed bin Abdullah bin Yusuf, Jamal Al-Din, Ibn Hisham, (d.: 761 AH), investigation: Dr. Mazen Al-Mubarak - Muhammad Ali Hamdallah, Damascus - Dar Al-Fikr, sixth edition, 1985 AD.
Vocabulary in the stranger of the Qur’an, Abu Al-Qasim, Al-Hussein bin Muhammad known as Al-Ragheb Al-Asfahani, (T.: 502 AH), investigation: Safwan Adnan Al-Daoudi, Damascus, Beirut - Dar Al-Qalam, Al-Dar Al-Shamiya, first edition, 1412 AH.
The Understanding of what is Confused by Summing up the Book of Muslim, Abu Al-Abbas, Ahmad Bin Omar Bin Ibrahim Al-Ansari Al-Qurtubi, (T.: 656 AH), investigation: Muhyi Al-Din Deeb Misto, Youssef Ali Badawi, Ahmed Muhammad Al-Sayed, and Mahmoud Ibrahim Bazzal, Publisher: Damascus - Beirut, Dar Ibn Katheer - Dar Al-Kalam Al-Tayyib, first edition, 1417 AH - 1996 AD.
Al-Muqni’ in the Sciences of Hadith, Abu Hafs, Ibn Al-Mulqin Siraj Al-Din Omar bin Ali bin Ahmed Al-Shafi’i Al-Masry, (T.: 804 AH), investigation: Abdullah bin Yusuf Al-Juday’, Saudi Arabia - Dar Fawaz, first edition, 1413 AH.
Al-Muntakhab from the Musnad of Abd Bin Hamid, Abu Muhammad, Abd Al-Hamid Bin Hamid Bin Nasr Al-Kassi, and he is called: Al-Kashi with Al-Fath and Al-Ajam, (249 AH), investigation by: Sobhi Al-Badri Al-Samarrai, Mahmoud Muhammad Khalil Al-Saidi, Cairo - Library of the Sunnah, first edition 1408 AH - 1988 AD.
Imam al-Bukhari’s Approach in Correcting and Explanationof Hadiths through the Sahih Mosque,Abu Bakr Kafi, Beirut-Dar Ibn Hazm, first edition,1422 AH_2000 AD.
Encyclopedia of the sayings of Imam Ahmad bin Hanbal in Rijal al-Hadith and its causes, compiled and arranged by: Sayyid Abu al-Ma’ali al-Nuri - Ahmad Abd al-Razzaq Eid - Mahmoud Muhammad Khalil, Publishing House: World of Books, first edition, 1417 AH - 1997 AD.
The End in Gharib Hadith and Athar, Abu Al-Saadat, Al-Mubarak bin Muhammad bin Muhammad bin Muhammad bin Abdul Karim Al-Shaibani Al-Jazari Ibn Al-Atheer, (T.: 606 AH), investigated by: Taher Ahmad Al-Zawi - Mahmoud Muhammad Al-Tanaji, Beirut - Scientific Library, 1399 AH - 1979 AD.
Yaqut and pearls in the explanation of the elite of Ibn Hajar, Zain al-Din Muhammad called Abd al-Raouf bin Taj al-Arefin bin Ali bin Zain al-Abidin al-Hadadi and then al-Manawi al-Qaheri, (d.: 1031 AH), investigation: Al-Murtadha al-Zain Ahmed, Riyadh - Al-Rushd Library, first edition, 1999 AD.
Concepts in documentation and weakening of the modern critics of Sharif, d. Hossam: Mashkor Awad, published research in the Journal of Islamic Sciences at Tikrit University, Issue (25), year: 2016 AD.
The hadiths of Imam Amr bin Shuaib, the cause of the difference in the ills of Al-Dar Qatni (a critical study), d. Ghazi Nayef Hamid, research published in the Journal of Islamic Sciences at Tikrit University, Issue: (42), Section (1), Year: 2019 AD.